I am
reading “The Catcher in the Rye”, a novel by J.D. Salinger. The book starts off
with this teenage kid named Holden Caulfield, talking about how he’s had a fine
life and his family and everything. After that he starts talking about the
school he recently attended called “Pencey Prep”. He tells the reader about the
school a bit and what he didn’t like about it. That, to me, is the whole intro
where he gives a little bit of his story and an idea of the situation he is in.
Now I
have read up to a part where he is talking to this old man who seemed to be a
teacher from the old school. By now I have gotten a good idea of his personality,
he is slightly negative with a hint of pessimism in the way he explains and
talks about things. I can tell by the way he talks that he can see some of the
illusions in life and doesn’t like how a lot of things are but he keeps it to
himself. For example, he always talks
about words or phrases he hates and gets off the story he is talking about just
to tell the reader how much he hates something. In this part where he is with
the old man, Mr. Spencer, he hears Mr. Spencer say “I had the privilege of meeting
your mother and dad when they had their little chat with Dr. Thurmer some weeks
ago. They’re grand people”. After Old Spencer says that, Holden starts talking
about how he hates the word “grand”. Which
is pretty funny to me right now but I can see his negativity in things getting
old and annoying later in the book.
I can also see at the part of the
book I am reading, that he didn’t really care for the exam paper he had to
write for Mr. Spencer about Egyptians. Mr. Spencer told him to go get it and
read it out loud to him. He was saying the whole time how he knew it was a trap,
or in his words “a dirty trick”, right when Mr. Spencer brought up the paper and
how it made him really mad. Mr. Spencer pointed out how he wrote a couple
decent paragraphs then was done with the paper. This really made Mr. Spencer
mad but Holden didn’t seem to care too much because he wasn’t interested in
what Mr. Spencer was teaching. This probably explains why he failed all his
other classes too, because he didn’t care enough to try and pass.
In the essay Holden wrote a note to
Mr. Spencer saying “I’m sorry that is all I know about Egyptians. I didn’t find
them very interesting… It is alright with me if you flunk me though as I am
flunking everything else except English anyways”. In this part he showed how he
didn’t want to make the teacher feel bad about flunking him but he didn’t even
care if he was flunked. I’m not sure why he hasn’t started caring about school
and why he spends time with this teacher if he doesn’t like school, it doesn’t make
a lot of sense yet but it probably will as I keep reading.
Mr. Spencer is his English teacher, right? and that's the only class he's passing. Have you ever seen anything like that-- a student failing everything, but passing one class. Maybe Holden likes English, and maybe he kind of likes Mr. Spencer. Sounds like he doesn't like writing about the Egyptians. Holden is telling us this story, so maybe deep down, he likes writing. Maybe that's one of the reasons I like him. Too bad he's flunking out of school.
ReplyDeleteI was curious as to who Mr. Spencer is? Is he the old man he is talking to at the begginning of your second paragraph. Is the story so far just talking about Holden or has a plot been developed yet?
ReplyDelete